1. Originally Posted by steve_bank
p1 All Greeks are geeks
p2 Joe is a Greek
p3 Not all geeks are Greeks

Which of the following conclusions are valid.
c1 Joe is a Greek geek
c2 Joe may or may not be geek.
C1 appears to follow from p1 and p2.

2. Yes p3 is extraneous.

3. An axiom in classical logic.

If a = b and b = c then a = c.

A rock weighs 100kg. A log has the same weight as the rock. A boat weighs the same as the log. Therefore the boat weighs 100kg.

Logically why is this valid? What is the proof of the axiom?

4. Is it possible to be hypercritically hypothetical?

5. Oh. I remember.

Dough-ah

6. Originally Posted by steve_bank
Is it possible to be hypercritically hypothetical?
Dam spell checker, s it possible to be hypothetically hypothetical?

7. hypothetically for argument's sake.

Dumb da dumb dumb, dumb da dumb, dumb da dumb de dumb ....

Joe

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•