1. ## 1 = -1

1 = -1

Proof:

-1 = i^2 = SQR(-1)*SQR(-1) = SQR[(-1)(-1)] = SQR[(-1)^2)] = SQR(1) = 1

QED!

Prove me wrong!  Reply With Quote

2. Originally Posted by SLD 1 = -1

Proof:

-1 = i^2 = SQR(-1)*SQR(-1) = SQR[(-1)(-1)] = SQR[(-1)^2)] = SQR(1) = 1

QED!

Prove me wrong!
SQR(1) != 1

SQR(1)={1,-1}

Also, i != SQR(-1), but SQR(-1)={i,-i}  Reply With Quote

3. As in algebra texts is
sqrt(1) =+-1.
sqrt(1) = 1
SQRT(-1) = i, A complex number [0 + i]. i^2 = -1. i^3 = 1...

sqrt(4) = 2
sqrt(-4) = sqrt(-1*4) = [0 + i2] or just i2  Reply With Quote

4. Originally Posted by SLD 1 = -1

Proof:

-1 = i^2 = SQR(-1)*SQR(-1) = SQR[(-1)(-1)] = SQR[(-1)^2)] = SQR(1) = 1

QED!

Prove me wrong!

1=\=-1.

I just proved you wrong. So, there is something wrong with your computation, and the only candidate is the SQR function, not defined for negative numbers (though if you want to try to define such a function ).  Reply With Quote

5. If your calculator has a complex number mode it will take sqrt(-1).  Reply With Quote

6. Originally Posted by steve_bank If your calculator has a complex number mode it will take sqrt(-1).
You can define a function on the real line (or in the complex field, for that matter) and call it "sqrt". However, it will not be an extension of the function defined on [0,+\infty) with the property that sqrt(x)sqrt(y)=sqrt(xy). This is actually proven by SLD's argument.  Reply With Quote

7. Originally Posted by Angra Mainyu  Originally Posted by steve_bank If your calculator has a complex number mode it will take sqrt(-1).
You can define a function on the real line (or in the complex field, for that matter) and call it "sqrt". However, it will not be an extension of the function defined on [0,+\infty) with the property that sqrt(x)sqrt(y)=sqrt(xy). This is actually proven by SLD's argument.
All numbers are complex. It is the top category. Reals are complex numbers with zero imaginary. My HP calculator does complex numbers as does most software packages. It is just trigonometry.
I
In software you can code the sqr function nay way you like. If you limit t to solely reals sqr(-1) is undefined.

The OP argument is counter to any high school algebra text. The quadratic equation. If the discriminant is negative the solution is complex, if not the solution is real.  Reply With Quote

8. Originally Posted by SLD Prove me wrong!
Division by zero is undefined.  Reply With Quote

9. Originally Posted by steve_bank  Originally Posted by Angra Mainyu  Originally Posted by steve_bank If your calculator has a complex number mode it will take sqrt(-1).
You can define a function on the real line (or in the complex field, for that matter) and call it "sqrt". However, it will not be an extension of the function defined on [0,+\infty) with the property that sqrt(x)sqrt(y)=sqrt(xy). This is actually proven by SLD's argument.
All numbers are complex. It is the top category. Reals are complex numbers with zero imaginary. My HP calculator does complex numbers as does most software packages. It is just trigonometry.
I
In software you can code the sqr function nay way you like. If you limit t to solely reals sqr(-1) is undefined.

The OP argument is counter to any high school algebra text. The quadratic equation. If the discriminant is negative the solution is complex, if not the solution is real.
Again, you can define a function on the real line (or in the complex field, for that matter) and call it "sqrt". However, it will not be an extension of the sqrt function defined on [0,+\infty) with the property that sqrt(x)sqrt(y)=sqrt(xy). This is actually proven by SLD's argument.  Reply With Quote

10. sqr(-4 * 9) = sqr(-1) * sqr(4) * sqr(9) = [0 + i6]

[0 + i6]^2= [0 + i6] * [0 + i6] = i^2 * 6^2 = -1*36 = -4 * 9

sqr(-1) = i, i^2 = sqr(-1) A definition.  Reply With Quote

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•